top of page

It’s a Thick Line Between Bad Guys and Villains

As a seasoned script connoisseur with a plethora of scripts under my belt,I mean hundreds over the last 6 years ranging from the beautifully crafted to the downright cringe-worth, I have consistently found myself drawn to one crucial element that can make or break a narrative: the presence of a compelling villain. Now, let's be clear from the outset, I’m not talking about your run-of-the-mill bad guys who simply engage in mischief for the sake of it. No, my friends, what I'm after, and what I believe elevates a script to new heights, is the intricacy and moral depth of a well-developed villain.

A Bad Guy, as we commonly encounter, is the one-dimensional character who's in it for the thrill or personal gain, robbing banks just because they can. Frankly, that's the stuff of yawns and eye-rolls. What truly captivates me, as a producer and avid script enthusiast, is the emergence of a Villain, a character with a moral mission, someone whose actions are driven by a deeper purpose that challenges not only the protagonist but the very fabric of morality and ethics within the story.

Think of Thanos from the Avengers franchise, a character who, despite his ruthless means, was pursuing what he believed to be a morally just goal. This distinction between bad guys and villains is paramount, as it shapes the essence of a script, giving it layers of complexity and elevating it from mediocrity to masterpiece.

As a producer, I can attest that the presence of a well-crafted villain is often the first thing I seek when evaluating a script—because, let's face it, a compelling antagonist is what separates the wheat from the chaff in the world of storytelling. So, let's dive into the realm of moral dilemmas, twisted ideologies, and the art of crafting villains that resonate long after the credits roll.

The Bad Guy's Dull Dance:

In the vast landscape of scripts, bad guys are a dime a dozen. They often lack depth, existing solely to create obstacles for the hero or to serve as a convenient source of conflict. Their motivations are usually shallow—money, power, or sheer malevolence without rhyme or reason. These characters seldom inspire thought or introspection; instead, they're content with being a plot device rather than an integral part of the narrative.

Consider the generic bank robber who revels in chaos for the sake of chaos. While such characters might add a momentary thrill, they fail to leave a lasting impact on the audience. Their actions lack a moral compass, and their presence becomes forgettable in the vast sea of indistinguishable antagonists.

The Villain's Symphony of Morality:

Now, let's shift our focus to villains—the maestros of moral ambiguity. These characters are not driven by a desire for chaos or personal gain alone. Instead, they embark on a journey fueled by a moral mission, a belief system that challenges the very foundation of the story. The villain sees themselves as the hero of their own narrative, often clashing with the protagonist over conflicting ideologies.

Take Thanos, for instance. His goal, however monstrous, stems from a twisted sense of morality, a belief that wiping out half of all life in the universe is a necessary evil to restore balance. This moral clash, this battle of ideologies, is what elevates a script from mere entertainment to a thought-provoking exploration of ethics.

Avoiding Clichés:

One pitfall many screenwriters stumble into is the temptation to rely on clichés when creating villains. The mustache-twirling, one-dimensional evildoer has become a tired trope. Break free from these clichés by infusing your villains with authentic motivations, making them relatable on some level, even if their actions are abhorrent.

Consider the grey areas of morality—sometimes the most compelling villains are those whose motives, while misguided, harbor a semblance of logic or righteousness. This complexity not only captivates audiences but also distinguishes your script in a saturated market.

A Producer's Perspective:

As a producer who has sifted through countless scripts, I can attest that a well-developed villain is like striking gold. It's the character that stays with you, leaving an indelible mark on the overall script. When evaluating a project, I look for more than just explosions and daring escapades; I seek a narrative that delves into the intricate dance between protagonist and antagonist, exploring the shades of gray that make storytelling an art form.

So Dear Screenwriters, don't settle for the mundane world of bad guys. Challenge yourselves to create villains with a purpose, characters whose moral dilemmas mirror those of the protagonists, adding layers of complexity to your narrative. Remember, a script's true prowess lies not just in the hero's journey but in the compelling dance between right and wrong. So, go ahead, craft villains that resonate, provoke, and ignite discussions long after the final act unfolds. Your audience, and discerning producers, will thank you for it.


bottom of page